posting on a sunday!

Act One

Before the Lobotomy from American Idiot (Sam)
Sam is in college, living with his girlfriend, Jessica. He has a dream about his family, specifically about Dean, and is disappointed when he wakes up and discovers it was only a dream. The next day, Dean shows up.

If You Were Gay from Avenue Q (Dean (and Sam))
If Sam was gay, Dean would like him anyway.

Pharaoh’s Dream Explained from Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat (Sam)
Sam tells Dean about the dreams and visions he’s been having of the future.

Can’t Fight This Feeling from Rock of Ages (Sam and Dean)
They go their separate ways because Sam wants to find John while Dean wants to work a job John sent them on. While apart, they privately express the feelings they have towards each other that they would never admit to.

I Wish I Could Go Back to College from Avenue Q (Sam)
Dean thinks he and Sam are going to continue hunting together after they kill the demon that killed their mom and Jessica, but Sam has other plans.

Hopelessly Devoted to You from Grease (Dean)
Dean thinks about how he would do anything for his brother who wants to leave him to go back to college.

Know Your Enemy from American Idiot (John (and Sam and Dean))
Sam and Dean find John, but they have trouble working together when he keeps trying to give them orders while they hunt a group of vampires in search of a gun that can kill demons.

If I Were a Bell from Guys and Dolls(Sam)
When Sam feels guilty about not being about to save everybody, he gets drunk and makes Dean promise he’ll kill him if he turns evils…but not before he nearly tells Dean how he feels about him.


I Am the One from Next to Normal (Dean)
Dean tells Sam he’s not going to kill him, and he’s going to keep anything bad from happening to him and keep him from doing anything bad.

Somewhere that’s Green from Little Shop of Horrors (Sam)
While hunting a djinn, Sam wakes up and finds himself in an alternate reality in which he and Dean live in a suburban home together and are raising a family.

I’d Give My Life for You from Miss Saigon (Dean)
Dean watches over Sam who has been stabbed to death and tells him how he always tried to protect him but now feels he’s failed. He then makes a decision to make a deal with a demon to save Sam’s life.

Poor Unfortunate Souls from The Little Mermaid (Crossroads demon)
Dean sells his soul.

Don’t Do Sadness from Spring Awakening (Dean)
Dean tries to convince Sam and himself that he’s not afraid about going to hell.

21 Guns from American Idiot (Sam and Dean (and whole cast))
Sam and Dean try to find a way to save Dean from going to hell, determined not to give up. Then, after an encounter with a dream version of himself, Dean wonders if he’ll be missed when he dies.

Wanted Dead or Alive from Rock of Ages (Sam and Dean)
With just hours left before Dean goes to hell, he and Sam share one last brotherly moment.

-------------------------------

Act Two

I’m Alive from Next to Normal (Dean
Dean comes back from hell and Sam and Bobby have a hard time believing it’s really him.

Going Through the Motions from Once More with Feeling (Dean)
Dean tells Sam he doesn’t remember hell, but he actually remembers it all and wishes he couldn’t feel anything.

My Eyes from Doctor Horrible’s Sing-Along Blog (Sam and Ruby)
Sam has started drinking demon blood and he expresses his feelings that “evil inside of him is on the rise” while Ruby tries to convince him that she’s trying to help him.

9 to 5 from 9 to 5 (Sam, Dean (and whole cast))
Sam and Dean are in an alternate reality where they aren’t brothers, don’t even know each other, and work in a marketing office.

I Am the One reprise from Next to Normal (Sam and Dean)
Sam has started the apocalypse and Dean tells Sam he doesn’t know if he can trust him anymore.

I Dreamed a Dream from Les Miserables (Sam)
Sam thinks about the past few years, and also hopes that he can be forgiven, especially by Dean.

Before the Lobotomy reprise from American Idiot (Sam and Dean)
After agreeing that Sam needs to take a break from hunting and that they’re better off apart, Sam and Dean each go off on their own and find themselves dreaming of the good old days.

What You Feel from Once More with Feeling (Lucifer)
Sam and Dean try to kill Lucifer with the Colt, but it doesn’t work.

Like Father, Like Son from Aida (Dean and Michael)
When Sam and Dean go back in time to save Anna from killing their parents. Michael uses John as a vessel and tells Dean that it’s his destiny to say yes to him.

Going Down from Hair (Sam)
Sam says yes to Lucifer.

What You Feel reprise from Once More with Feeling (Lucifer)
Lucifer tells Dean that Sam is long gone.

Where Do We Go from Here from Once More with Feeling (Dean, Castiel, and Bobby)
Lucifer is back in his cage, but they feel anything but victorious. They go their separate ways.

Without You from Rent (Dean)
One year later, Dean is living with Lisa, but is finding it hard to live a normal life when the person he loves more than anyone else in the world is gone.

I’m Alive reprise from Next to Normal (Sam)
Sam is back from hell and has been for nearly a year.

I’ve Got a Theory from Once More with Feeling (Sam, Dean, and Bobby)
Sam and Dean return to their life of hunting together.

I Should Tell You from Rent (Sam and Dean)
Sam gets his soul back and he and Dean finally tell each other what they’ve been feeling for years and what they should have said long ago.

Touch Me from Spring Awakening (Sam and Dean)
Sam and Dean finally act on the sexual tension that has been building up for longer than they’d ever admit.

The Final Countdown from Rock of Ages (Sam and Dean (and whole cast))
They prepare for a final battle that they likely won’t come out of alive.

Last Night on Earth from American Idiot (Sam and Dean)
Sam and Dean are about to die together and go to heaven, but not before they express one last time what they’ve meant to each other.

download